THE LIMITS OF THE STATE: PROVISIONING, HEALTH CARE AND SOCIETAL AID IN CHILDREN’S INSTITUTIONS OF TURKESTAN AND EARLY SOVIET UZBEKISTAN
Malika Kh. Murodova
Researcher, National University of Uzbekistan named after Mirzo Ulugbek, Tashkent, Uzbekistan
Keywords: child welfare; famine relief; health care; orphanages; family placement; charity; Turkestan; Uzbek SSR; American Relief Administration
Abstract
However elaborate the legal and pedagogical design of Soviet children’s institutions, their real effectiveness depended on elementary material conditions: food, clothing, buildings, medical care and money. This article examines these conditions in the orphanages and labour communes of the Turkestan ASSR and, later, the Uzbek SSR, and the ways in which the state’s shortfalls were partly compensated by charitable organisations, international relief, local communities and, above all, the placement of children in families. Drawing on archival documents, press reports, and Uzbek, Russian, Kazakh and Anglophone scholarship, the article argues that material provision, nutrition and health care formed the “weakest link” of the system: official budgets and food norms looked impressive on paper but were repeatedly unfulfilled, funds were sometimes misdirected, qualified medical staff were scarce and unevenly distributed, and the quality of care depended heavily on geography and on the energy of local leaders. Charity and community support complemented the state but could not close the gap; the most extensive form of assistance was family placement, which reached more children than institutions and may be seen as the Soviet-era continuation of older traditions of mutual help. The article distinguishes between direct material results and the broader social effects of aid, and flags evidence dating from after 1924.
References
1. Usmanov, F. A. (2026). Child homelessness and neglect in the Uzbek SSR in the second half of the 1920s: Statistics, social portrait, and systemic crisis analysis. International Multidisciplinary Science Conference, 1(5), 171–176.
2. Khuzhanova, M. F. (2016). Istoriya detskikh domov v Uzbekistane: formirovanie, deyatelnost i problemy (1920–1930 gg.) [History of orphanages in Uzbekistan]. Molodoi uchenyi, 19(123), 284–288. (In Russian)
3. Cameron, S. (2018). The Hungry Steppe: Famine, Violence, and the Making of Soviet Kazakhstan. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
4. Slavko, A. A. (2011). Detskaya besprizornost i beznadzornost v Rossii kontsa 1920-kh – nachala 1950-kh godov (Doctoral dissertation abstract). Samara. (In Russian)
5. Maslova, O. B. (2010). Likvidatsiya massovoi detskoi besprizornosti v Sovetskoi Rossii v 1920-e gody (Candidate’s dissertation abstract). Pyatigorsk. (In Russian)
6. Saktaganova, Z. G., & Karsakova, G. B. (2017). Vliyanie goloda na rost chisla besprizornykh detei v Akmolinskoi gubernii v 1920-e gg. Vestnik KazNU, Seriya istoricheskaya, 3(86), 5–9. (In Russian)
7. Buttino, M. (1990). Study of the economic crisis and depopulation in Turkestan, 1917–1920. Central Asian Survey, 9(4), 59–74.
8. Kamp, M. (2019). Hunger and potatoes: The 1933 famine in Uzbekistan and changing foodways. Kritika, 20(2), 237–267.
9. Rasulov, A. N. (2016). Turkiston va Rossiya xalqlari o‘rtasidagi munosabatlar. Tashkent: Turon-Iqbol. (In Uzbek)
10. Mamadaliev, Sh. (2023). Coverage of famine and starving children in the press (1917–1924). International Journal on Integrated Education, 6(12), 277–291.
11. Khalid, A. (n.d.). Turkestan v 1917–1922 godakh: Borba za vlast na okraine Rossii. shosh.uz. (In Russian)
12. National Archive of Uzbekistan (NAU), f. R-86, op. 1, d. 4399, l. 16.
13. Tashkent Regional State Archive, f. 530, op. 1, d. 1193, l. 7.
14. Izvestiya, December 1919; Izvestiya, 11 December 1921.
15. NAU, f. R-94, op. 1, d. 123, l. 53.
16. NAU, f. R-94, op. 1, d. 86, ll. 9–10.
17. NAU, f. R-17, op. 1, d. 398, l. 3.
18. NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 3133, ll. 3, 24–25.
19. NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 3133, ll. 31–32, 71.
20. NAU, f. R-86, op. 10, d. 674, l. 8.
21. NAU, f. R-94, op. 5, d. 1713, l. 38.
22. Kaipbaeva, A. T., Kozybaeva, M. M., Mukhatova, O. Kh., Baizhumanova, Z. B., & Bekenova, A. A. (Comps.). (2025). Iz istorii borby s detskoi besprizornostyu v Kazakhstane i sopredelnykh stranakh v 1920–1930-e gg. Almaty: Balausa. (In Russian); NAU, f. R-17, op. 1, d. 398, l. 3.
23. Lukashina, V. (2019, September 2). Deti Grazhdanskoi voiny: Besprizorniki 1920-kh godov. vatnikstan.ru. (In Russian)
24. Ball, A. (1994). And Now My Soul Is Hardened: Abandoned Children in Soviet Russia, 1918–1930. Berkeley: University of California Press, pp. 40–55.
25. NAU, f. R-86, op. 1, d. 8034, l. 120.
26. NAU, f. R-25, op. 1, d. 682, l. 600.
27. Rasulov, A. N. (2011). Turkiston xalqi bag‘rikengligi (XX asr 20-yillari boshlarida Rossiyadan evakuatsiya qilingan bolalar misolida) [The tolerance of the people of Turkestan: the case of children evacuated from Russia in the early 1920s]. Tashkent: Yangi nashr, pp. 15–17. (In Uzbek)
